Sunday, 15 November 2026

சுரங்கப் பகுதியில் காணப்படும் இயற்கையான கதிர்வீச்சு பாதிக்காது – பாபா அணு ஆராய்ச்சி மையத்தின் (BARC) அறிக்கை

 உலக அளவில் அதிக கதிர்வீச்சு கொண்ட பகுதி கொல்லம் மாவட்டத்தில் இந்திய அருமணல் ஆலைக்கு சொந்தமான சுரங்க பகுதி ஆகும். வழக்கம் போல் ஒரு குறிப்பிட்ட நிறுவனத்தை பிடிக்கவில்லை என்றால் கதிர்வீச்சு என்ற புகார் எழுப்புவது போல் அந்த நிறுவனத்திற்கு எதிராகவும் புகார் எழுப்பப் பட்டது. இந்திய அரசு அணுசக்தி துறை கட்டுப்பாட்டில் உள்ள பாபா அணுசக்தி ஆராய்ச்சி நிறுவனம் மற்றும் சில நிறுவனங்களோடு சேர்ந்து ஒரு ஆராய்ச்சி செய்து அப்பகுதியில் உள்ள மக்களுக்கு எந்த பாதிப்பும் இல்லை. அவர்கள் கதிர்வீச்சு இல்லாத பகுதியில் உள்ள மக்களைப் போல் ஆரோக்கியமாகவும், நோய்கள் இன்றியும் இருக்கிறார்கள் என அறிக்கை சமர்பித்து உள்ளார்கள். இந்த விபரத்தை ஒரு ஊடகம் வெளியிடுகிறது. இதே நிலை தமிழகத்தில் என்றால் அந்த அறிக்கையை விமர்சித்து அவர்கள் கல்லா கட்டி இருப்பார்கள். ஆனால் இது உண்மை நிலையை மக்களுக்கு தெரியப்படுத்துகிறது. அந்த ஆங்கில செய்தி இதோ.


No Extra Germline Mutations Found in Kerala’s High Natural Radiation Areas.


People living along India’s Kerala coast have long absorbed some of the highest natural background radiation levels on Earth, thanks to monazite-rich beach sand laced with uranium and thorium. A new whole-exome sequencing study now reports that decades of chronic, multi-generational exposure to this radiation have not left a detectable burden of extra germline mutations in their blood cells. The findings, published in the journal Genes and Environment, come from researchers at the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre and collaborating institutions who compared healthy men from high level natural radiation areas (HLNRAs) with matched controls from adjacent normal level areas (NLNRAs).

The study focused on twelve randomly selected, healthy male donors, six from each group. Individual dosimetry, performed with Geiger-Muller tube-based survey meters placed in each participant’s home and adjusted for age- and sex-specific occupancy factors, showed that the HLNRA group received a mean annual absorbed dose of 31.8 ± 5.4 mGy per year, while the NLNRA controls averaged just 0.9 ± 0.2 mGy per year, roughly a thirty-fold difference. Mean ages were closely matched at 43.0 years in both groups, and all participants were male, which allowed the researchers to rule out age and sex as confounding factors in mutation frequency. Written consent and lifestyle information, including smoking, alcohol use and medical radiation exposures, were collected under ethics approval from the Medical Ethics Committee at BARC.

From peripheral blood mononuclear cells, the team isolated genomic DNA and prepared exome libraries that were sequenced in paired-end mode on an Illumina HiSeq 2500 platform, achieving a mean coverage of roughly sixty-fold. Reads were mapped to the human reference genome hg38 using the Sarek pipeline, and germline variants were called with two independent tools, Strelka and GATK HaplotypeCaller, with only variants supported by both callers retained. To isolate a possible radiation signature, the researchers filtered out common polymorphisms with a minor allele frequency above one percent recorded in the gnomAD and genomeAsia100K databases.

After filtering, 17,431 variants remained, comprising 15,695 single nucleotide variants (SNVs) and 1,736 small insertions or deletions (indels). The exposed and control groups carried remarkably similar totals: 8,624 mutations (7,744 SNVs and 880 indels) in the HLNRA group versus 8,807 mutations (7,951 SNVs and 856 indels) in the NLNRA group. Average per-person SNV counts were likewise nearly identical, at 1,290 SNVs (28.4 per megabase) in the exposed group and 1,325 SNVs (29.2 per megabase) in controls. Non-synonymous missense mutations made up the largest mutation class in both groups, at about 20 percent, and the genomic distribution of variants across regulatory, intronic, ncRNA and splicing regions was broadly comparable.

Protein-affecting mutations, which include missense, frameshift, stop-gained, in-frame deletion and splice-site changes, also showed no significant difference between groups, with 1,925 in the exposed group and 2,082 in controls. Pathway analysis using the Reactome database revealed that genes carrying these mutations in each group were involved in similar critical functions, including DNA repair, immune response, chromatin organization, RNA splicing and cell-cell communication. Notably, when the researchers compared their variants against a curated list of cancer predisposition and DNA damage response genes, the exposed group actually carried fewer affected cancer predisposition genes, seven versus twenty in the control group, with only BRCA2, NBN and related repair genes represented.

Predictive tools reinforced this picture. Using REVEL, which scores missense variants for pathogenicity, the team identified around 145 potentially pathogenic mutations in the exposed group versus 187 in controls, with no increase in variants linked to carcinogenesis among the radiation-exposed men. The AloFT tool predicted 25 loss-of-function stop-gain mutations with high impact in the exposed group compared with 37 in controls. Taken together, the authors conclude that chronic low-dose radiation exposure at these levels did not measurably increase the germline mutational burden or the load of potentially harmful protein-altering variants.

One signal did stand out. Principal component analysis of five-nucleotide sequence contexts showed elevated C to T frequencies in the exposed group at contexts such as CA[C>T]GG and CC[C>T]GG. Because methylated cytosine at CpG sites readily deaminates to uracil, producing C to T changes, the authors suggest this pattern may reflect differential DNA methylation at CpG islands in the exposed population, possibly an epigenetic response to chronic low-dose radiation. They note that their own unpublished methylation data on selected DNA repair genes, and prior promoter methylation studies after acute irradiation, are consistent with this interpretation, though they caution that larger cohorts and genome-wide methylation profiling are needed to substantiate it.

The results align with a broader body of evidence from Kerala and other high background radiation regions. Epidemiological studies cited by the authors have found no increase in congenital malformations, adverse pregnancy outcomes, hereditary anomalies or cancer incidence in the Kerala HLNRAs, or in China’s Yangjiang region. Cytogenetic and molecular assays, including gamma-H2AX and 53BP1 foci analysis, have generally not shown dose-dependent increases in DNA double-strand breaks in Kerala’s exposed population, and earlier studies there reported efficient repair of DNA breaks, although a few studies in China and Ramsar, Iran, and one recent Kerala study limited to female inhabitants, reported elevated chromosomal aberrations in small samples. Transgenerational whole-genome sequencing of children born to Chernobyl clean-up workers and atomic bomb survivors likewise found no significant increase in germline de novo mutations.

The authors are careful about scope. The study is limited by its small sample size, only six donors per group, partly because individuals receiving background doses above 20 mGy per year constitute only about 0.5 percent of the HLNRA population, making participants from the highest-exposure clusters inherently scarce. Whole-exome sequencing also captures only protein-coding and nearby functional regions, not the full spectrum of alterations in regulatory or non-coding DNA. The observed C to T enrichment at CpG sites remains an association suggestive of methylation-related processes, not a demonstrated causal mechanism, and the authors emphasize that future work should employ whole-genome sequencing alongside genome-wide methylation and epigenetic profiling, with stratified dose categories, to establish definitive dose-response relationships.

Even with those caveats, the study offers a rare direct measurement in humans rather than an extrapolation from mice or drosophila, on which current linear no-threshold risk models have historically relied. By showing that men carrying roughly thirty times the background dose of their neighbors carry no excess of germline SNVs, indels, protein-affecting mutations or predicted pathogenic variants, the work adds concrete population-level evidence to a long-standing debate about the genetic risks of chronic low-dose ionizing radiation, and points toward epigenetic adaptation, rather than accumulating DNA damage, as the more intriguing thread to follow next.

Source : https://bioengineer.org/no-extra-germline-mutations-found-in-keralas-high-natural-radiation-areas/


Friday, 4 September 2026

Inputs for Stakeholder consultations for Strengthening India’s Critical Mineral Ecosystem

Copy of Email send by our company Managing Partner Mr.S.Vaikundarajan e-mail to Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries, New Delhi for our members information. 

**********

Dear Sir

Sub:  Inputs for Stakeholder consultations for Strengthening India’s Critical Mineral Ecosystem

With reference your email  dated August 11,2026 on the above subject , we submit  herewith of inputs and suggestions for discussions during stakeholder consultation .

 

1.      India hosts large resources ( 35% of global resources ) of heavy mineral placer deposits along the coastal stretches of Andhra Pradesh, Tamilnadu, Orissa and Kerala. These beach placers contain a multi-mineral suite of high-value minerals comprising – Titanium rich minerals ( ilmenite, rutile  and leucoxene ) , Zircon, Garnet, Sillimanite and REE rich Monazite which occur together and their individual contents vary from deposit to deposit. These high-value minerals and their derivatives find diverse applications in day-to-day use as well as strategic and high-tech applications.

 

2.       In spite of the vast resources ,  the Beach Sand minerals (BSM) remain grossly underutilised, with the production-to-reserve ratio (PRR) being a meagre 0.0018 % when compared to the global PRR of 0.01%. Consequently, India has to rely on imports of minerals and derivative products to meet domestic demand and faces supply chain uncertainties due to global economic and geopolitical challenges.

 

In this scenario, beach sand minerals containing strategic and critical Ti minerals ( ilmenite and rutile ) , Zircon and REE’s rich monazite present substantial opportunities for mining and downstream value addition to boost domestic production, ensuring supply chain security, stimulating socio-economic development and making India self-reliant.

 

3.      To accelerate India’s capability to implement and operationalise the                                         “Mine to Magnet “ value chain to meet the domestic critical mineral requirements, India should focus on its largely untapped beach sand mineral resources along its coastline. These beach sand deposits contain Titanium rich minerals Ilmenite and Rutile, Zircon which are classified as critical and strategic minerals under Part D of the MMRD act. Further, Monazite is rich in Rare Earth elements , like Cerium, Lanthanum, Neodymium, Praeseodymium, and other valuable REE’s which are used in manufacture of magnets widely used in Automotive , Aerospace , Defence and Military and High tech applications.

 

 In order to accelerate India’s production of critical minerals, the following action plan is suggested

 

i.                     Reopen the BSM sector to private participation under a strictly regulated framework .

 

ii.                   Allow private sector participation  to mine all BSM minerals, with monazite handed over to the government or processed in public-private partnerships.

 

iii.                 Such an initiative will bring in capital investment  and technology  to realise the full value chain and

a.      Create employment  in the industrially backward coastal regions

b.      Guarantee  uninterrupted supply of ilmenite  to TiO₂ (Titanium dioxide) based industries—the white pigment manufacturing (used in paints, plastics, etc.)  and reduce import dependence on Chinese supply       

c.       Save foreign exchange by reducing  TiO₂ pigment imports and achieve  self -reliance

d.      Promote value addition through synthetic rutile, titanium slag, and other downstream products like rare earth magnet manufacturing, etc

e.      Enable  India achieve self-sufficiency in rare earths production and TiO2 pigment production  and eventually become a global exporter.

 

            India must act before the technological advancements develop substitute materials

            whereby the current mineral resources  would lose relevance and remain as a buried

            treasure.

 

 

4.      Prior to 2016 ,  several private mining leases operated in Tamilnadu, Andhra Pradesh and Kerala. All these private mining companies after recovering their permitted material garnet, ilmenite, zircon and rutile, were also generating Monazite ( REE ) rich Tailings.  Atomic Energy Regulatory Board imposed a condition that, when the monazite percentage is less than 2% in these tailings, it had to be blended with the silica sand and backfilled in the mined out area.  However,  if the monazite percentage was  more than 5%, the private lessees were advised to store these tailings in a separate place after recovering other minerals. Accordingly, during the course of their operations ,some of the private mining lessees in Tamilnadu and Andhra Pradesh have accumulated  several lakh  metric tonnes  of such tailings  which contain critical minerals and Rare Earths minerals.  

 

These accumulated tailings are a readily available REE-rich resource and can be an immediate solution for quick extraction and processing to produce the much needed critical and REE minerals for domestic requirements.  The Government may prescribe necessary conditions for recovery of valuable mineral and dispose of the same within India to the end-users or the value added producers as raw material.  This will not only provide immediate raw material for critical mineral and REE production in India , but will also be a significant initiative from the stand point of  mineral conservation and maximum utilisation of our country’s natural resources.

 

Mineral Exploration is a capital-intensive, time-consuming, high-risk activity being fraught with uncertainties associated with new mineral discoveries.   While this is an essential activity and must be pursued, it does not present an immediate solution to the supply shortages of critical minerals and REE for domestic production. Therefore, a prudent and balanced approach would be to operationalise the critical minerals and REE available in these  tailings immediately while parallelly pursuing exploration for new mineral discoveries for future production and raw material security.

 

 

5.      Regulatory and clearance delays

 

Mining projects often face delays due to environmental, forest and land related approvals. The Government should ensure speedy clearances for smooth implementation of the projects.

 

 

6.      Infrastructure  requirements in project areas

 

Many deposits are located in remote areas with weak logistics , power and water infrastructure  which require significant capital expenditure for development and therefore adversely impact project viability. Government must facilitate and ensure required support for infrastructural development so that the burden of infrastructure development does not fall on the private investor.

 

 

7.      Develop R &D ecosystem for technological know-how.

 

India’s existing mineral processing technologies still need further development for processing the critical minerals.  Further, India’s R &D ecosystem for processing of critical minerals is still at a nascent stage and has limited ability to support  commercial scale production. Hence a well-coordinated and focused collaboration between academic and industrial research institutions is needed  for the development of required technology and  supported by an R& D ecosystem  to develop cost-effective solutions for domestic critical minerals production

 

 

Thanking You

 

 

Yours Truly


 S.Vaikundarajan

Sunday, 4 January 2026

மேக் இன் இந்தியா என்பது வெறும் பேச்சளவில் மட்டுமே உள்ளது. எந்த அதிகாரியும் அதனை செயல்படுத்த தயார் இல்லை.

 இந்திய அரசு மேக் இன் இந்தியா என்ற ஒரு உன்னதமான திட்டத்தை அறிமுகப்படுத்தியது. அதன்படி அனைத்து பொருட்களையும் இந்தியாவிலேயே உற்பத்தி செய்ய வேண்டும். அதற்கு அரசு எல்லா உதவிகளையும் செய்யும். இது மிகப் பெரும் விளம்பரமும் செய்யப் பட்டது. இவ்வாறு இந்திய அரசின் கொள்கை இருக்கும் போது இந்தியா இல்மனைட்டில் இருந்து உற்பத்தி செய்யப்படும் டைட்டானியத்தை சீனாவில் இருந்து இறக்குமதி செய்கிறது. இதற்கு காரணம் தனியார் இல்மனைட் சுரங்க பணிகள் நிறுத்தப் பட்டு இந்திய அரசு நிறுவனமான ஐஆர்இஎல் மட்டுமே தற்போது இல்மனைட் குவாரி செய்கிறது. இவர்கள் இந்தியாவில் உள்ள டைட்டானியம் உற்பத்தியாளர்களின் இல்மனைட் தேவையை பூர்த்தி செய்வதில்லை. மாறாக ஒரு பகுதி மட்டும் வழங்கி ஒரு பகுதியை சீனாவிற்கு நேரடியாக ஏற்றுமதி செய்கிறார்கள். எனவே இந்திய டைட்டானியம் உற்பத்தியாளர்கள் அதிக விலை கொடுத்து இல்மனைட்டை வெளிநாட்டில் இருந்து இறக்குமதி செய்ய வேண்டியது உள்ளது. எனவே இவர்களது டைட்டானியம் விலை கூடுதலாகி விடுகிறது. ஆனால் மிகக் குறைந்த விலைக்கு இந்திய அரசு நிறுவனத்தின் இல்மனைட்டை கொள்முதல் செய்யும் சீனா குறைந்த விலையில் டைட்டானியத்தை உற்பத்தி செய்து இந்திய டைட்டானியம் நிறுவனங்களிடம் விலை போர் நடத்துகிறது. இந்திய அரசின் எந்த அலுவலரும் இதனை கண்டு கொள்வதில்லை. இதனால் இந்தியாவில் உள்ள மொத்தம் ஐந்து டைட்டானியம் உற்பத்தியாளர்களில் கோல்மாக் கெமிக்கல்ஸ் மற்றும் ஜெனித் மெட்டல்ஸ் ஆகிய நிறுவனங்கள் தொழிலையே மூடி விட்டார்கள். எனவே இன்னும் மூன்றே மூன்று நிறுவனங்கள் மட்டுமே இந்தியா முழுவதும் டைட்டானியம் உற்பத்தியில் உள்ளன. அவற்றை இந்திய அரசு நிறுவனத்தின் சரக்கை வாங்கும் சீனா அடிக்கிறது. தற்போது இந்திய அரசு செய்ய வேண்டியது (1)  சீனாவில் இருந்து இந்தியாவிற்கு டைட்டானியம் இறக்குமதி செய்யும் போது இறக்குமதி வரியை கூட்டி விதிக்க வேண்டும் அல்லது (2) இந்திய டைட்டானியம் உற்பத்தியாளர்களுக்கு தேவையான இல்மனைட்டை சப்ளை செய்து மிகுதியாக இருக்கும் இல்மனைட்டை மட்டுமே ஏற்றுமதி செய்ய வேண்டும் என ஐஆர்இஎல்-க்கு தடை விதிக்க வேண்டும். (3)டைட்டானியம் உற்பத்தியாளர்களுக்கு தேவையான இல்மனைட்டை அவர்களே குவாரி செய்து கொள்ளலாம் என சுரங்க குத்தகை வழங்க வேண்டும். 


இவ்வாறு எந்த நடவடிக்கையும் எடுக்கவில்லை என்றால் தற்போது அமெரிக்கா புலம்புவது போல் இந்தியா புலம்பும் காலம் வெகு தொலைவில் இல்லை. மேக் இன் இந்தியா என்பது ஒரு கவர்ச்சிகரமான பேச்சாக மட்டுமே அமைந்து விடும். 



Tuesday, 29 April 2025

விவி மினரல் நிறுவனத்திற்கு எதிரான வழக்கில் உச்சநீதிமன்றம் இடைக்கால தடை

கடந்த பிப்ரவரி மாதம் சென்னை உயர்நீதிமன்றத்தில் ஒரு பரபரப்பு தீர்ப்பு தாது மணல் சம்பந்தமாக வழங்கப் பட்டது. அதாவது இருக்கின்ற தாதுமணல் அனைத்தையும் அரசிடம் ஒப்படைக்க வேண்டும் மற்றும் பல ஆயிரம் கோடி ரூபாய் ராயல்டி மற்றும் தொகை செலுத்த வேண்டும். சிபிஐ வழக்கு பதிவு செய்து விசாரிக்க வேண்டும் உட்பட ஏராளமான உத்தரவுகளில் அதில் பிறப்பிக்கப் பட்டது. இதனை எதிர்த்து எங்கள் விவி மினரல் நிறுவனம் சார்பில் உச்சநீதிமன்றத்தில் சிறப்பு அனுமதி மனு தாக்கல் செய்யப் பட்டது. அதில் நாங்கள் முறைப்படி தேவையான அனைத்து அனுமதிகளையும் பெற்றுள்ளோம். அரசுக்கு உரிய ராயல்டி செலுத்தியே கனிமங்களை போக்குவரத்து செய்துள்ளோம். எங்களிடம் சுற்றுச்சூழல் அனுமதி மற்றும் சுரங்க திட்ட அனுமதி போன்ற இந்திய அரசிடம் பெற வேண்டிய அனுமதிகளும் உள்ளன. நாங்கள் ஒவ்வொரு கனிமத்தையும் அரசுக்கு ராயல்டி செலுத்தி அரசின் இயக்க அனுமதி சீட்டோடே எடுத்து வந்துள்ளோம். இதனை எங்கள் எழுத்துபூர்வ வாதுரையில் ஆவணங்களுடன் சமர்பித்துள்ளோம். (எழுத்துபூர்வ வாதுரை https://vetri3337.blogspot.com/2025/04/blog-post.html- ல் உள்ளது)


இந்த விபரங்களை நீதிமன்றத்தில் எடுத்துரைக்கவும் செய்தோம். உயர்நீதிமன்ற உத்தரவு பத்தி 75 முதல் 100-ல் இதனை காணலாம்.


VII. Contentions of the Respondents:

Key Points of Contentions by the 8th and 22nd Respondents:

75.        The 22nd Respondent claims that his competitors out of rivalry have instituted the present PIL. The 8th Respondent claims that they have a valid mining lease from the State Government with the previous approval of the Central Government as well as Atomic Energy Department. The 8th Respondent stated that they have a valid mining plan duly approved by Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration (AMD) and the Indian Bureau of Mines (IBM) which had approved the scheme of mining also. It was also stated that they have a valid Environmental Clearance from Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF&CC) for all its mining leases and that the production also is within the limit of EC as well as approved mining/scheme of mining and they also stated that they have a valid consent under Air Act and Water Act.

76.        It was contended that the Amicus Curiae did not highlight any violations of the India Rare Earths Limited (IREL), but instead pointed out imaginary violations against the 8th Respondent’s mining lease. The 8th Respondent further leveled allegations of serious mining violations against IREL. It was further contented that the Amicus Curiae did not apply the reverse calculation method for the IREL and that he did not prepare chart citing violations by IREL.

77.        It was contented that the Amicus failed to act impartially and that though Amicus discussed about the Bedi report in his volume of charts, Amicus did not point out that Bedi committee did not inspect Trichy and Madurai Districts.

78.        It was further contended that principles of Natural Justice was violated only for the 8th Respondent. Inspections of leases belonging to the 24th, 25th and 8th Respondents were conducted based on directions of the High Court. However Natural Justice Principles were violated only with respect to the 8th Respondent. Further, the 8th Respondent alleges that the Amicus failed to point out the illegalities and violations committed by the

24th and 25th Respondents. The 8th Respondent further contends that the Amicus did not collect documents from official government agencies and that he did not rely on official data.

79.        The 22nd Respondent goes on to level allegations against Mr.D.Dhaya Devadas that he had engaged Retired officials to make complaint against the 8th Respondent. The 8th Respondent further claims that totally 40 allegations were leveled against the company and that all allegations were thoroughly enquired and rejected by the State Government and reported to the Government of India vide its Principal Secretary letter

No.7810/MMD2/2011-1 dated 23.07.2013. The 8th Respondent claims that IREL colluded with Mr.D.Dhaya Devadas.

80.        It was submitted that the Customs Department did not point out any irregularities against the 8th Respondent, however it is alleged by the latter that the 24th and 25th Respondents export is more than the permit obtained quantity.

81.        The 8th Respondent contended that the Amicus Curiae method of calculation of royalty is wrong. This was substantiated by stating that all the quantity transported by the 8th Respondent is below the quantity permitted by MoEF and permitted by mining plan/scheme of mining and that the variation is solely due to replenishable deposits. Further, it was submitted that all the quantities were transported with valid permits.

82.        Further, it was submitted that the 8th Respondent is permitted to produce other minerals from the existing tailings accumulated vide competent authority 2nd Respondent letters dated 05.05.2000 and

05.06.2000, without fresh mining lease and also that the 1st Respondent had confirmed the same, vide letter dated 16.08.2000. Hence, based on the above said approval letters issued by competent authorities, the 6th and 7th Respondents permitted the 8th Respondents to produce minerals from existing accumulated tailings available with 8th Respondent.

83. It was contented that the case of Common Cause vs. Union of

India and Others[1], is not applicable to the 8th Respondent. The 8th Respondent relied on paragraph 129 of the judgment, as follows:

“129. The simple reason for not accepting this interpretation is that Rule 2(ii-a) of the MCR was inserted by a Notification dated 26-7-2012 while we are concerned with an earlier period. That apart, as mentioned above, the holder of a mining lease is required to adhere to the terms of the mining scheme, the mining plan and the mining lease as well as the statutes such as the EPA, the FCA, the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981. If any mining operation is conducted in violation of any of these requirements, then that mining operation is illegal or unlawful. Any extraction of a mineral through an illegal or unlawful mining operation would become illegally or unlawfully extracted mineral.”

On relying in this paragraph, the 8th Respondent averred that they have necessary approvals and clearances as under the Act and Rules.

84.        It was further contended that the 8th Respondent has not engaged in illegal mining. And that with respect to Bedi Committee, the 8th Respondent claims it to be not statutorily valid. It was further averred that there is no excess stock with respect to 8th Respondent as per Sahoo Committee report.

85.        It was averred by the 8th Respondent that with respect to monazite, there are no possibilities for export of monazite as there are no countries where thorium is used for any purpose. And that the allegation of export of monazite by M/s.V.V. Mineral is wrong.

86.        It was also submitted that the reverse calculation method for royalty adopted by Amicus is wrong. It was submitted that this calculation is not based on physical verification or inspection or seizure by competent empowered officials.

87.        The 8th Respondent's total sales are 57,71,688 MT. 15,000 divided by 38,77,391 = 0.0038685 x 57,71,688 = 22327.77 MT of Monazite should be available. Whereas the 8th respondent having the following quantity of Monazite.

 

Actual Stock 38,77,391 M.Ton

Content of Monazite 15,000 M.Ton

Already export local sales quantity 57,71,688

M.Ton

23,408 M.Ton instead of 22327 M.Ton

 

This will establish that the reverse calculations are wrong according to the analysis report documents of Amicus.

88.        The excess quantity is the quantity collected from the already sold minerals prior to 2000. So, the reverse calculation method adopted by Amicus is defeated by his own analysis documents produced from AMD.

89.        Further contentions of the 8th Respondent are that as per Section 5(2)(b) of MMDR Act, the State Government, cannot grant the mining lease without the approved mining plans. Also as per Rule 22(5) of MCR, 1960 the mining plan should contain the tentative scheme of mining - That means the quantity mentioned in the mining plan is only tentative. The quantity and annual program are only tentative and the replenishable quantity can be collected by the lessee if it is deposited within the lease hold area as already decided by the Court in W.A.No.69 of 1998 and W.P.No.5386 of 1997. As per Rule 22(6) of MCR, 1960 the mining plan once approved will be valid for the entire lease period and that 8th Respondent has the valid mining plans for all its mines. As per Rule 9(2) of Mineral Conservation and Development Rules, 1988 (MCDR, 1988), the Controller General or the authorized officer may require the holder of a mining lease to make such modification in the mining plan or impose such conditions as he may be consider necessary by an order in writing, if such modification or imposition of conditions are considered necessary. Accordingly, 8th Respondent has obtained modified mining plan also for certain lease areas.

90.        It was averred that the Government of India, IBM issued separatemanual for preparation and approval of mining plans after prior inspection. So without verification no mining plan will be approved and hence the Amicus allegation about mining plan has no basis.

91.        The 8th Respondent averred that none of the Act and Rules for payment of royalty or mining operation has been violated by the 8th respondent. It was submitted that the entire 3rd report of the Amicus is without any statutory violation and that this report regarding royalty and his enclosures 15A and 15B has no legal value.

92.        Regarding Monazite the 8th Respondent contends that the percentage of occurrence of monazite in BSMs is a natural phenomenon and claims that they have requisite handling license and that they are permitted to store the monazite tailings. Based on the aforementioned grounds the 8th and 22nd respondent sought for dismissal of this PIL.

Key Contentions of 16th, 17th, 18th, and 19th Respondents:

93.        It was mainly submitted that Monazite is a radioactive material

and cannot be clandestinely smuggled across National/International borders. Every atomic mineral have traces of radioactive mineral, which cannot be separated and that National and International regulators have fixed permissible threshold. It was submitted that checkpoints at Airports and Harbours are installed with radioactive detectable scanners as per International guidelines stipulated by International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). There is also clear National and International mechanism to monitor the movement of radioactive materials including monazite across borders.

94.        With regard to allegations of excess mining it was averred that in BSM, the presence of percentage of minerals are not certain. Sometimes due to tidal action and wind action, the deposits will be more and some time there won't be even any deposit. So when excess minerals are got from BSM, it is declared before the Lessor. The lessor can either confiscate the excess minerals and say it is in excess of the mining plan and hence it belongs to the State or royalty can be collected and in the present case the lessor has chosen the latter and the royalty collected was audited and duly shared between the Centre and the State. Therefore question of evasion does not arise.

95.        It was submitted that every form of mineral which was exported have suffered royalty and properly declared. There must be a mismatch in the interpretation of quantum of royalty to be collected whether on the ad valorem price of Orissa or Tamil Nadu is but a technicality and not evasion.

96.        It was submitted that the respondent company was granted lease by order dated 01.03.2004 for a period of 30 years for doing Beach Sand Mining and pursuant to the mining lease the hundreds of crores of Rupees was invested and the mining plan was set up. Further, more than 10,000 direct and indirect employments were created due to the trade. Further, huge amounts of royalty was paid and foreign exchange revenue worth hundreds of crores was generated by exporting beach sand minerals. Surprisingly the Government of Tamil Nadu vide G.O.Ms.No.318 dated 25.11.2021 terminated the lease of this respondent prematurely stating that Government of India has amended the Atomic Mineral Concession Rules, 2016.

97.        It was averred that the amendment is nothing but a clear case of colorable legislation in order to favour Government companies, who are all competitors to the petitioner company. There is no reasonable classification and object sought to be achieved by the specific amendment. Further there is no rational nexus. The beach sand minerals may have minor radioactivity which cannot be separated and that all are handled by both Government and private companies.

98.        It was submitted that the ratio laid down in Common cause judgment (Supra) which deals about static miserable reserve does not apply to the case of BSMs. It was further submitted that the MMDR Act is not a control Act but a development oriented Act.

99.        It was averred that the repeated criticism of mining of BSM would cause environmental issue is a gross generalization without any regard to factual aspects. BSM are unique and they are the only mineral which are replenishable in nature. The replenishment was also recognised by the learned Amicus in his report. The Nagar Committee assigned by Department of Atomic Energy also has recognized fact of replenishment.

100.     With regard to royalty it was contented that whatever amount calculated in whatever means either in the form of royalty towards ROM has to be treated as advance royalty. Therefore the entire quantities of mineral exported by the respondents are royalty stuffed. And excess royalty amount collected in the Department of Geology and Mining is still with the

Government.

 

 மேற்கண்ட எங்களது வாதுரைக்கும் ஆதாரங்களுக்கும் எந்த பிரதிவாதியும் மறுத்து ஆதாரம் சமர்பிக்கவில்லை என்பன போன்ற அனைத்து உண்மைகளும் மேண்மை தங்கிய உச்சநீதிமன்றத்தின் முன்பு எடுத்து வைக்கப் பட்டது. அவற்றை பரிசீலித்த மேண்மை தங்கிய உச்சநீதிமன்றம் எங்கள் தரப்பு ஆவணங்களை பரிசீலித்து உயர்நீதிமன்றத்தின் உத்தரவிற்கு இடைக்கால தடை விதித்து தற்போது உள்ள நிலையே தொடர வேண்டும் என ஆணை பிறப்பித்து உள்ளது என்ற விபரத்தை இதன் மூலம் தெரிவித்துக் கொள்கிறோம்.







Friday, 21 July 2023

எல்லாவற்றிலும் முத்திரை பதிக்கும் விவி மினரல் அண்ணாச்சி நிர்வாகம்

 உலக அளவில் தாதுமணல் கையிருப்பில் மூன்றில் ஒரு பங்கை வைத்திருக்கும் இந்தியா, உற்பத்தியில் உலக அளவில் 14-வது இடத்தில் இருந்தது. விவி மினரல் நிறுவனம் உற்பத்தியை தொடங்கி ஏற்றுமதியை ஆரம்பித்த பிறகு இந்தியா படிப்படியாக முன்னேறி 9, 7, 5, 3, 2, 1 என உலக அளவில் முதல் இடத்தை தொடர்ந்து கைப்பற்றி வந்தது. அந்நிய சதியால் இந்த தொழில் முடக்கப் பட்டதால் எங்களை போன்ற பல ஆயிரம் தொழிலாளர்கள் பாதிக்கப் பட்டதோடு இந்தியாவும் உலக அளவில் தாதுமணல் உற்பத்தியில் மீண்டும் 7-வது இடத்திற்கு சென்று விட்டது. 






இந்திய ஆட்சி பணிக்கு பயிற்சி கொடுக்க வேண்டும் என்ற சீரிய நோக்கத்தோடு எங்கள் நிர்வாகம் காஞ்சிபுரம் மாவட்டம் வாலாஜா அருகில் உள்ள ஆதி பொறியியல் கல்லூரியை எடுத்து நிர்வாகத்தை அண்ணாச்சியின் மருமகன் திரு. சரண்ராஜ் அவர்கள் வசம் ஒப்படைத்தார்கள். இந்த கல்லூரி 2015-ல் எடுக்கப் படும் போது 364-வது இடத்தில் இருந்தது. 2016-ல் 231, 2017-ல் 134, 2018-ல் 48, 2019-ல் 15, 2022-ல் 11-வது இடம் என படிப்படியாக முன்னேறிக் கொண்டே வருகிறது. பிரபலமான நிறுவனங்களின் பொறியியல் கல்லூரிகள் மற்றும் ஏராளமான அரசு பொறியியல் கல்லூரிகளும் எங்கள் நிறுவன நிர்வாக கல்லூரிக்கு பின்னாலேயே இருப்பது எங்களுக்கு மகிழ்ச்சியாகவே உள்ளது. முழு பட்டியல் கீழே கொடுக்கப் பட்டுள்ளது.

ஆதி பொறியியல் கல்லூரி பற்றி மேலதிக விபரம் வேண்டுவோர் https://www.adhi.edu.in/index.php  இணைப்பை பார்வையிடவும்.














Wednesday, 30 March 2022

சுற்றுச்சூழல் பாதிப்பு இல்லாத தாதுமணல் சுரங்க பணி

இரும்பு தாது சுரங்க பணி வெடி வைத்து ஒரே நேரத்தில் தகர்க்கப் படுகிறது. ஆனால் தாது மணல் சுரங்கம் வேளாண் கருவிகள் உதவியோடு இலகுவாக எடுக்கப் படுகிறது.